Whats QBs from this era should make the Hall of Fame.
Options
kuskklassic
Members Posts: 1,006 ✭✭✭✭
Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are locks for the Hall of Fame but what other QBs from this era should make the HOF ???
Drew Brees (1 ring)
Eli Manning (2 rings, beats Patriots twice)
Big Ben (2 rings)
over time these three guys will get in.
Donavan McNabb (NFC champ. appearances, Superbowl appearcances)
Steve McNair (AFC champ. appearances, Superbowl appearances)
the ony two black QBs to make it from this era (sorry, Vick)
Drew Brees (1 ring)
Eli Manning (2 rings, beats Patriots twice)
Big Ben (2 rings)
over time these three guys will get in.
Donavan McNabb (NFC champ. appearances, Superbowl appearcances)
Steve McNair (AFC champ. appearances, Superbowl appearances)
the ony two black QBs to make it from this era (sorry, Vick)
Comments
-
Wrong forum ? , unless you mean tv qbs....
-
-
af.r.i.c.a. wrote: »
-
Rodgers
-
5 Touchdowns in one game??
Shiiiiiiiiiiiiiid. Canary Yellow jacket like a mug, shawty. -
currently playing? P. Manning, Brady, Brees are locks. Nobody else
-
Brees is a lock IMO
45,919 yards
324 TD's
94.3 Rating
3 5,000 yards season
1 Superbowl Ring
1 Superbowl MVP
-
Surprised nobody hyping up Rodgers..
-
Jeremyiahest83 wrote: »Surprised nobody hyping up Rodgers..
he could never play the nfl ever again. if thats the case he won't make it. so he's not a lock. -
I'll tell you who shouldn't be there. Tony Romo.
-
[img]http://? .static.falcons.clubs.nfl.com//assets/images/imported/ATL/photos/person-cards/players/player-cards/JPGs/H-N/PlayerCard_LukeMcCown.jpg[/img]
Get Mad. -
McNair and McNabb?
McNabb was never really great he was just good for a long time. Atleat IMO.
McNair got dome-checked in his sleep by some 19 year old he was cheating on his wife with and you think he belongs in hof? gtofh 5
Right now, I think Brees, Brady, and Manning.
Recently retired I think Favre is a lock. Someone on the fence might be Kurt Warner. -
greenwood1921 wrote: »[img]http://? .static.falcons.clubs.nfl.com//assets/images/imported/ATL/photos/person-cards/players/player-cards/JPGs/H-N/PlayerCard_LukeMcCown.jpg[/img]
Get Mad.
He looks more like a kicker than a quarterback. -
What does mcnair getting shot have to do with the hof @willmunny
-
Kurt Warner is a lock IMO also.
-
What does mcnair getting shot have to do with the hof @willmunny
Anyone who gets killed by their jumpoff does not deserve to be in the hof... -
yea i do believe Kurt Warner deserves Hall of Fame honors. Not first ballot tho
Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Brett Farve are the only garaunteed locks.
Drew Brees & Eli Manning right behind them.
Aaron Rodgers makes it if wins another ring and put up consistant numbers rest of his career
Big Ben(got 2 rings but that was most Steelers defense)...may still have a shot if he wins another one.
Phillip Rivers & Tony Romo too many mistakes and they underachieved almost every year. wont make it.
Matt Ryan, Joe Flacco to early to tell.
-
1st ballot hall of famers
Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers, Bret Favre
non 1st ballot hall of famers
Ben Roethlisberger, Phillip Rivers, Eli Manning, Donavon McNabb, Kurt Warner, Steve McNair
-
Kurt Warner won a superbowl, superbowl MVP, and two league MVPs. He's obviously making it to the hall of fame.
-
I think McNabb is closer than a lot of people believe. Over 37000 yards passing,over 200 TD passes..above .500 playoff record..I think he gets in but it will take awhile. As a Titans fan I would love to see McNair get in..but I think he's a 50-50 guy at best.
Kurt Warner was always an interesting case to me because either he was extremely productive or injured and unproductive. From 1999-2001 he was dominant. From 2002-06 he was almost non existent and from 2007-09 productive again. So six very good/great yrs, five poor/non productive years. I believe he'll eventually get in though.
The only way Vick will get in is if they look at him as athlete who had a Bob Hayes type influence at QB. Meaning he changed the way scouts looked at attributes to have in a QB and the way defenses needed to change their schemes to adjust to him, similar to how defenses had to develop zone defenses to limit Bob Hayes because of his speed. -
How the ? I forget about my ? Favre.
-
I may be bias but yall ? hating on Brees.
-
greenwood1921 wrote: »[img]http://? .static.falcons.clubs.nfl.com//assets/images/imported/ATL/photos/person-cards/players/player-cards/JPGs/H-N/PlayerCard_LukeMcCown.jpg[/img]
Get Mad.
? Brees, y'all ? hatin' on ^^^ that cat. Dude had a flawless season this year. -
Call me crazy but.. ^^^^ that ain't Matt Ryan. Looks like a 4 on that jers. Matt wear #2.
-
Jeremyiahest83 wrote: »Call me crazy but.. ^^^^ that ain't Matt Ryan. Looks like a 4 on that jers. Matt wear #2.
That's McCown the GOAT. You mad?
