Jay-z & Timbaland "Big Pimpin" Case Dismissed
Options
_Goldie_
Members, Moderators, Writer Posts: 30,349 Regulator
in The Reason
A judge on Wednesday dismissed a copyright infringement case against rapper Jay Z over his 1999 hit Big Pimpin' before the case was sent to a jury.
U.S. District Judge Christina A. Snyder ruled that the heir of an Egyptian composer did not have the right to pursue a copyright infringement claim and the case should be tossed out.
The nephew of Baligh Hamdi, an Egyptian composer whose 1957 song Khosara Khosara is partially used in Big Pimpin', sued Jay Z, producer Timbaland and several media companies in 2007. Flute notes that Hamdi composed appear throughout the Jay Z song, and nephew Osama Ahmed Fahmy claimed they had exploited Khosara Khosara without proper permission.
"We think it's completely wrong, and we'll appeal," Fahmy's attorney, Pete Ross, said after the ruling."
The abrupt end to the case came after the rapper and Timbaland testified about creating the rap hit and their belief that they had valid rights to use the Egyptian song.
Timbaland paid $100,000 US in 2001 to settle a claim about usage of Hamdi's song, which was written for a 1957 film, and testified that he believed he had valid rights to use it.
His attorney, Christine Lepera, praised the ruling, saying the hit-making producer had maintained throughout the eight-year case that he didn't infringe on any copyrights to create the music for the rap song.
Jay Z, whose real name is Shawn Carter, also said he thought he had a valid licence to use the flute notes for the song that became his first major hit single.
"My client is pleased with and gratified by the decision," Jay Z's attorney Andrew Bart said.
Comments
-
The user and all related content has been deleted.
-
If they cleared the sample I don't see why it was a problem in the first place.
Another issue is that after a certain length of time the song becomes public domain.
Anybody know why they dismissed the case? It seems pretty obvious that thats where the sample came from. -
The user and all related content has been deleted.
-
I forgot Big Pimpin was Jay-Z song
-
Naw some ? like clearance rules in the US and International being different or some ? like that I think
-
-
Got em
-
Jay with another W
-
Jay was cracking jokes while being drilled on the stand...that dude is the definition of cool, calm n collected
-
natural born sinners wrote: »Jay was cracking jokes while being drilled (Pause) Grilled on the stand...that dude is the definition of cool, calm n collected
-
-
If they cleared the sample I don't see why it was a problem in the first place.
Another issue is that after a certain length of time the song becomes public domain.
Anybody know why they dismissed the case? It seems pretty obvious that thats where the sample came from.
Jay walked in , flashed the diamond sign then walked out ... for more details, it's the link below.
http//www.camelsinsecretsocieties/illumaniti666.com
-
Off the top, the 2 things I remember most about that video is the yacht and the woman with big tittys.
-
It's like I said in the other thread. They had legal clearin' for the sample but not the 'moral' clearin'. A joke of a case
-
Fun Facts: ? asked to borrow Big Gipp flow on this song. That car in the background is his car, he bought a day before the shoot & he ended up smashing Gloria Velez later that day.
Where was Stacy Dash at in the video? -
T. Sanford wrote: »Fun Facts: ? asked to borrow Big Gipp flow on this song. That car in the background is his car, he bought a day before the shoot & he ended up smashing Gloria Velez later that day.
Where was Stacy Dash at in the video?
Which Gipp flow? -
T. Sanford wrote: »I forgot Big Pimpin was Jay-Z song
Chad clowned on that ? and he hated that damn song to the day he died. ? aint want ? to do with Jay-Z and was scared to fly over water to Trinidad so he shot that ? in Miami.
Killed the verse
Disrespected J'
Ran off and freaked the hell outta Gloria in her prime
But props to J' for beating the suit, get ready to hear some more of that lucky lefty ? on records. -
T. Sanford wrote: »Fun Facts: ? asked to borrow Big Gipp flow on this song. That car in the background is his car, he bought a day before the shoot & he ended up smashing Gloria Velez later that day.
Where was Stacy Dash at in the video?
Which Gipp flow?
That bouncy flow, you can tell that was Pimps first time experimenting with it. He made it work, the rest is history. -
"His first major hit single"
What happened to "Can I Get A" or " Hardknock Life" -
Did they mention the company Tim paid for the sample when he first got it?
-
uncommonsense wrote: »T. Sanford wrote: »Fun Facts: ? asked to borrow Big Gipp flow on this song. That car in the background is his car, he bought a day before the shoot & he ended up smashing Gloria Velez later that day.
Where was Stacy Dash at in the video?
Which Gipp flow?
That bouncy flow, you can tell that was Pimps first time experimenting with it. He made it work, the rest is history.
Yeah but which one specifically?
I remember when Gipp was promotin his album he said he used a different flow on each track... I'm just wondering if there was a track that's comparable... -
If I wudn't rapping baby, I would still be ridin' Mercedes
-
UGK did a great job with that record, Jay was cool too.
-
I just watched that video again for the first time in years. Timbaland on there looking like Kenan Thompson.
-
T. Sanford wrote: »Fun Facts: ? asked to borrow Big Gipp flow on this song. That car in the background is his car, he bought a day before the shoot & he ended up smashing Gloria Velez later that day.
Where was Stacy Dash at in the video?
Which Gipp flow?
He didn't say which one. I just remember him asking can he borrow his flow because he didn't know how to rap over that beat