Best Aftermath Album out of these four? (Em vs 50 Vs Game vs K Dot)
Options
DOPEdweebz
Members, Moderators, Writer Posts: 29,364 Regulator
Best Aftermath Album out of these four? (Em vs 50 Vs Game vs K Dot) 81 votes
The Marshall Mathers LP (2000)
7%
6 votes
Get Rich Die Tryin (2002)
37%
30 votes
The Documentary (2004)
14%
Good Kid Maad City (2012)
40%
33 votes
Comments
-
Oooo I was ready to vote Documentary mad quick didn't expect to see Maad City. Gimme a sec
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)Ive been thinking about doing this thread with all Dre's proteges including ? for years lol but im to lazy salute.
GRODT is in a close second, GKMC cohesiveness pushes it over the edge though.
-
Get Rich Die Tryin (2002)The Recipe wrote: »Ive been thinking about doing this thread with all Dre's proteges including ? for years lol but im to lazy salute.
GRODT is in a close second, GKMC cohesiveness pushes it over the edge though.
hip hop isnt for you if you think GKMC was anywhere near GRODT, even the documentary ? on it.
stop being a hipster ? , go outside
GKMC shoudlnt even be on the list -
Get Rich Die Tryin (2002)Gee_has_hot_picture wrote: »The Recipe wrote: »Ive been thinking about doing this thread with all Dre's proteges including ? for years lol but im to lazy salute.
GRODT is in a close second, GKMC cohesiveness pushes it over the edge though.
hip hop isnt for you if you think GKMC was anywhere near GRODT, even the documentary ? on it.
stop being a hipster ? , go outside
GKMC shoudlnt even be on the list
Truth -
The Documentary (2004)Thats a tough choice but when the documentary came out i was blown away..
-
GKCMC is the worst album on the list.
-
On first look, it's between GRODT and GKMC, but I'ma listen to all 4 again and come back to the thread.
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)Definitely out of Dot and Fif.
How can the classic MMLP have zero votes so far
-
Definitely out of Dot and Fif.
How can the classic MMLP have zero votes so far
Take a guess
-
I still think TES is Em's best album. If this was included, I prolly would've voted for it.
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)
Ummm people think the other albums are better? ??? -
En-Fuego22 wrote: »
That's possible! -
Good Kid Maad City (2012)It's between Kendrick and 50. I went with Kendrick's album because lyrically it's better. Production wise I would say both albums are equal.
-
wow that ones really tough....they are all great albums
-
Get Rich Die Tryin (2002)I'll go GROTD, with Doc 2nd being I listen to that more than the other selections
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)50 wasn't and isn't as lyrical or deep as Kendrick.
If the albums are a tie as far as quality , the content of Sing About Me, Im Real, and Dont ? My Vibe specifically are the tiebreakers. 50 cant/couldn't do that -
-
Get Rich Die Tryin (2002)Get rich dropped 2003
-
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)GKMC
Documentary
Mmlp
GRODT -
StoneColdMikey wrote: »GKMC
Documentary
Mmlp
GRODT
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)GKMC and then GRODT.
The crazy thing is that when I was young I thought MMLP was one of the hottest albums ever. Then I realized Em was talking nonsense mostly. It was just that he was saying shocking ass ? . It was entertaining. His best album is The Eminem Show imo. It was more introspective. -
Good Kid Maad City (2012)GKMC is the Best but possibly the least "aftermath-y" of them all. The others have Dre on production and features and you just feel Dre's presence more. Besides his feature on 1 of the last GKMC songs it just feels like Dre just backed a dope project to give it more clout
-
Good Kid Maad City (2012)GKMC > GRODT > Documentary > MMLP
Butthurted g unit fans may say otherwise, buts its the best overall album. -
Good Kid Maad City (2012)Took me a long minute, but i went with GKMC. All of the albums were dope, but Em's subject matter was his downfall, as was 50's, i understand he is a gangster, but he did not give us much more besides that and being a ? I thought The Massacre was a little better in that aspect had some great story songs like Baltimore Love Thing and others.
Game is kinda like 50, his production was dope as ? but the songs were all about being a gangster and name dropping folks. (aint heard the album in years im sure there was more to it but what i can remember is the gangster stuff at this second.)
GKMC had dope beats and touched on a bit of everything. We got to see a lot of different sides of him from story telling, partying, self reflection, and other ? . Was just a great project all around. They all were, but GKMC was the best to me.
