Who do you think has a better catalog: Jay-Z or Kanye?
Options
Comments
-
Yeezyyall overanalzying this ? .. aint nobody trying to say kanye a better rapper. its clearly jay. but kanye albums are better than jay's. jay has ? that is weak and disappointing. kanye does not. kanye has arguably atleast 3 classics.. same goes for jay. but damn near every other jay album is good to average to plain ? garbage. the other kanye albums are great to good. lyrics aint got ? to do for an album. if we discussing who is a better RAPPER then yeah but we not.
-
JaySorry for the titan. I have both these guys in my top 5 discography wise but when we compare Kanyes catalogue to any bonafide MC it can never just be "who better"
Also: Kanyes music is/was seen a breath of fresh air & he has that riding for him & is diefied b/c he speaks for a lot of people who didnt feel represented.
While Jay is someone who's albums & verses became the most in demand during a time when Hip Hop was dominating every aspect of youth & american culture. So there are totally different influences & factors when comparing their albums. Makin it more than just a song for song checklist
-
Yeezy? in here acting like kanye spits garbage and only his beats are hot
ye's lyrics are more nas'ish than Jay...jay only talks bout his damn self -
JaySmh ya'll acting like the jay " duds" didn't have gems on them bp2 the gift cd watcher, my way, dream, excuse me miss, hovi baby, the bounce all dope 6outta 11 I could add me and my girl friend too but anyway the curse cd you don't know, meet the parents, some how, some people hate, blueprint 2, ? please, what they gonna do, ? and sisters, show you how, 8 outta 15 and I like diamonds and guns and roses so really 10 outta 15 so outta 26 tracks 17 are dope. and this is considered a bad jay album gtfoh. Jay is that nugga !
-
Jayhow in the hell are kanye's albums better? has anyone actually listened to 808's or his ? fantasy....the ? sounds terrible, especially that last album...not sure what he was trying to do there but he was def trying to hard to break a mold or something and it didn't work out, easy as that
being different doesn't make it good, that albums noises were soo sloppy and just plain annoying, this is rap not broadway musical, push boundaries but do it so it sounds good not like trash
plus if nikki minaj as untalented as she is bodies every verse kanye spits on the whole album, in one verse then wtf -
YeezyNicki has some of the best ghost writer's in the game thanks to the YM affiliation though.
-
Yeezy? are reacting on emotions
-
YeezyLol ? mad damn
-
JayI don't think it is a good comparision because Jay has so much more work out. I might go Ye if it was since Ye was active but overall no.
-
JayKanye has great music.. in time there's a big possibility.. right now.. hov
-
JayThis ? is stupid
-
JayRodrigueZz wrote: »Nicki has some of the best ghost writer's in the game thanks to the YM affiliation though.
"It's going down, basement" -
JayKanye can not make an album better than REASONABLE DOUBT...
-
JayI honestly never saw the big deal with Kanye.....and the word classic gets thrown around way too much....lmao @ knaye having 3 classics....yeah ok
-
JayJay's Classics >>>>>>>>>> Ye's Classics
But the ironic thing is Ye played a role in one of Jay's Classics. -
Yeezygoing to base my vote purely on the average quality of each man's albums. they've both got a lot of merit in each of their catalogs and, i suppose, to some extent, the question is whether you're siding with the superior rapper or the superior producer. but ? it, going with Kanye here.
-
JayBumpin this thread just to say how proud I am of my Reason heads. Had me lost there for a min.
-
Jay^So basically one has strength in production and the other has strength in actual rapping? Thanks for the new info!
-
YeezyI know Kanye can't make an album better than AG, BP or RD but I thought we wefe talking about the average quality overall?
-
JayKanye Fest?........oh hell no
-
JayKanye will eventually surpass everyone.
-
YeezyKanye
-
YeezyKanye's catalog is more solid. Both have the same amount of classic albums (two), but Jay has 2-3 below average albums (Kingdom Come, BP2 and BP3) where Kanye arguably has one. Neither have an album that I would say was "wack", but Jay definitely has some albums that were underwhelming or below average.