Classic Or Not Vol 25 (Halloween Edition)............When The Smoke Clears............(Heated Race!)

Peezy_Jenkins

Yes

i wouldnt have voted for soul food either, but thats just me, i did expect it to make it in the vault tho.

5th Letter

No

T. Sanford wrote: »

Jamaica wrote: »

so let me get this straight soul food is NOT a classis but THIS is classic? smh.

because whoever voted against soul food is a ?

& they BOTH are Hip Hop classics

i don't think soul food is a classic. i'm just saying that soul food>>when the smoke clears

TwentyFive.Lighters wrote: »

Jamaica wrote: »

so let me get this straight soul food is NOT a classis but THIS is classic? smh.

Chill out bruh. People are gonna have different opinions than you. It's a forum for ? 's sake.

i'm expressing my opinion on this message board. no different than anybody else in this thread.

genocidecutter

Yes

@Jamaica and @SiriuslyHiii stay catching feelings. You lost three Six Mafia are dope period.

jono

No

Jamaica wrote: »

so let me get this straight soul food is NOT a classic but THIS is classic? smh.

I voted against both.

SiriuslyHiii wrote: »

This album should swap with Trap Muzik to cure the injustice TM101 received

I voted against that too *shrugs*

_Goldie_

Yes

2 of my favorite albums of alltime , ¨Eminem show¨and ¨the carter 2¨, practically got no votes, so there´s really nothing that suprises me concerning these polls....

FyHunnit

No

genocidecutter wrote: »

@Jamaica and @SiriuslyHiii stay catching feelings. You lost three Six Mafia are dope period.

The votes are split tho. I'm obviously not the only one that's saying it don't belong in the vault.

jono

No

We need 6 votes for the right outcome.

Brian B.

Yes

another album folks try to discredit w/ the "regional classic" smh

OGClarenceBoddicker

Yes

If it's from the South it's a "regional classic".

jono

No

SwampNigga wrote: »

If it's from the South it's a "regional classic".

If "classic" means OLD then yeah this album is "classic" but I thought we talking high quality over a decade, it seems to me like Southern ? just voting for this because its Southern.....can't say that though cuz a ? will get "wacked" and "no-signed" to death.

Southern ? aint no different than NY ? , they think everything they make is "classic".

Stew

Yes

The Carter 2 wasnt nearly this close in votes.

Matt-

No

only because Chapter 2: World ? is more of a classic to me. before they shifted their sound slightly. and i just can't give 3 6 two 'classic albums'

blackgod813

Yes

If u did another Carter 2 recount guran damn t. U it would go in or ill eat Bacon an kiss a white woman

Peezy_Jenkins

Yes

jono wrote: »

SwampNigga wrote: »

If it's from the South it's a "regional classic".

If "classic" means OLD then yeah this album is "classic" but I thought we talking high quality over a decade, it seems to me like Southern ? just voting for this because its Southern.....can't say that though cuz a ? will get "wacked" and "no-signed" to death.

Southern ? aint no different than NY ? , they think everything they make is "classic".

this is quality ? , it has nothing to do wit being from the south, i guess every classic gotta be rappity rap lyrical miracle ? huh

OGClarenceBoddicker

Yes

jono wrote: »

SwampNigga wrote: »

If it's from the South it's a "regional classic".

If "classic" means OLD then yeah this album is "classic" but I thought we talking high quality over a decade, it seems to me like Southern ? just voting for this because its Southern.....can't say that though cuz a ? will get "wacked" and "no-signed" to death.

Southern ? aint no different than NY ? , they think everything they make is "classic".

? how you gon critique some ? you don't listen to.

I be damn if i'm bout to tell you Reflection Eternal or Like water for chocolate or some ? ain't a classic.

This album had ? on smash when it dropped everybody was ? wit this ? and you ain't gotta skip ? . Sound like a classic to me. If you ask for impact, the whole game sound like this album today, ? in the underground and the mainstream. You speakin form a far.

Matt-

No

and i don't think it makes much sense to say that this album is a regional classic when this was their most "mainstream" album. the regional classics would be the ? that actually got people in the region listening to them in the first place

Matt-

No

but i understand my opinion here doesn't mean ?

OGClarenceBoddicker

Yes

Yay Hoe.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zq6d37k1PhA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNyjyaaOMn8


Album leavin footprints in the sand and ? like that thaarr.

Brian B.

Yes

matt- wrote: »

only because Chapter 2: World ? is more of a classic to me. before they shifted their sound slightly. and i just can't give 3 6 two 'classic albums'

yet another way to discredit

"they already made an album just as good that I think is classic, so I can't give them 2 classics" smh

sully

No

Can someone who voted 'yes' explain to me HOW this album is classic besides "every song is dope".

buttuh_b

No

Is this the most feelings caught in a classic or not thread to date?

Peezy_Jenkins

Yes

sully wrote: »

Can someone who voted 'yes' explain to me HOW this album is classic besides "every song is dope".

? really have to have more reason than this for it to b classic to them?

Brian B.

Yes

sully wrote: »

Can someone who voted 'yes' explain to me HOW this album is classic besides "every song is dope".

what else is there to explain?

if someone feels every song is jammin, how is it hard to see them sayin it's classic?

Jus cuz you don't agree?


I've seen folks on here call albums classic & even say there's a song or two they don't like.. can you explain that?

jayeight

Yes

It got ? C in it :P

sully

No

Brian B. wrote: »

sully wrote: »

Can someone who voted 'yes' explain to me HOW this album is classic besides "every song is dope".

I've seen folks on here call albums classic & even say there's a song or two they don't like.. can you explain that?

Influence on the genre as a whole.