Peyton Manning or Tom Brady ?

Options
1…567810

Comments

  • kAjUn
    kAjUn Members Posts: 2,439 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    ghost! wrote: »
    that and they felt they were more effective as an offensive when they werent dealing with a diva wide out., that's why they brought branch back as well.



    the nfl players picked brady over manning....

    I know but weren't they just voting off of last season?

    Cause all I kept hearing was you gotta go with Tom he was the mvp of 2011
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JUXcaptainHOOK
    JUXcaptainHOOK Members Posts: 406 ✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    kAjUn wrote: »
    I know but weren't they just voting off of last season?

    Cause all I kept hearing was you gotta go with Tom he was the mvp of 2011

    yea thats all it was just the AP voting from last year....

    we shall see who wins this year match up in week 13 ... i still think the colts are gonna meet the Patriots this years playoff... its been long enuff... "the road to the sb has to go thru New England" like they said in 07
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Madbeats
    Madbeats Members Posts: 544 ✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    I go with Peyton. His neck is still healing after surgery though so don't know how much he'll do this season.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • vageneral08
    vageneral08 Members Posts: 19,535 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    kAjUn wrote: »
    Majority of the population thinks Peyton is better

    Even with that said it still don't change my view that they're equal

    well you and few others feel that way but someone gotta win the vote
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • rapbizla
    rapbizla Members Posts: 86
    edited August 2011
    Options
    JUXcaptainHOOK wrote: »
    yea thats all it was just the AP voting from last year....

    we shall see who wins this year match up in week 13 ... i still think the colts are gonna meet the Patriots this years playoff... its been long enuff... "the road to the sb has to go thru New England" like they said in 07

    I don't know, I keep hearing that Manning's injury is worse than is being let out. He couldn't even turn his damn neck! If that's true, Indy won't do much this year. Plus, they looked terrible agains the Rams in the preseason game. I mean downright ugly.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • vageneral08
    vageneral08 Members Posts: 19,535 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    rapbizla wrote: »
    I don't know, I keep hearing that Manning's injury is worse than is being let out. He couldn't even turn his damn neck! If that's true, Indy won't do much this year. Plus, they looked terrible agains the Rams in the preseason game. I mean downright ugly.

    lol very false....he can move his neck he was throwing in training camp but not running the 1st team offense which will be big gamble because that o-line hasnt gotten the feel of playcalls from manning especially the rookies
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • ghost!
    ghost! Members Posts: 7,370 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    kAjUn wrote: »
    I know but weren't they just voting off of last season?

    Cause all I kept hearing was you gotta go with Tom he was the mvp of 2011

    It wasnt....they talked about each player for their careers, a lot of them talked about brady winning superbowls as well.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Jeezyfan4ever
    Jeezyfan4ever Confirm Email Posts: 1,034 ✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    JUXcaptainHOOK wrote: »
    I know it was just pre season... but homie from the Patriots put up 45 points last night light... lemme guess... he's the next great QB too right? ? outta here... Face the facts, its the system they have which played more of a role in Brady's rings as to Peyton Manning doing it basically individually and working harder for it

    I wouldn't say Brady had better coaching. It's not like Dungy and Moore were dog ? . like I said Dungy's staff with Moore etc wasn't chop liver. Polian is not a garbage GM. He knows what he's doing. Marvin Harrison, Dallas Clark, Reggie Wayne, Jeff Saturday, etc...are not scrubs.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Jeezyfan4ever
    Jeezyfan4ever Confirm Email Posts: 1,034 ✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    vageneral08 wrote: »
    well you and few others feel that way but someone gotta win the vote

    you right, but dont you think manning will win cause he more popular then brady, same ? with jeter when he got voted in the all start everyone knew he wasnt suppose be in the allstar with a .250 avg but guess what fans voted himm in cause everyone knows who jeter
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • vageneral08
    vageneral08 Members Posts: 19,535 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    Jeezyfan4ever wrote: »
    you right, but dont you think manning will win cause he more popular then brady, same ? with jeter when he got voted in the all start everyone knew he wasnt suppose be in the allstar with a .250 avg but guess what fans voted himm in cause everyone knows who jeter

    no manning is not more popular than brady they're bout the same.......every since the "rivalry" was created people now anticipate the game the regluar season game when they play each other
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Jeezyfan4ever
    Jeezyfan4ever Confirm Email Posts: 1,034 ✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    vageneral08 wrote: »
    no manning is not more popular than brady they're bout the same.......every since the "rivalry" was created people now anticipate the game the regluar season game when they play each other

    you wildin manning is the most popular QB in the league by far cause of commercial, his father played in the NFL
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • vageneral08
    vageneral08 Members Posts: 19,535 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    Jeezyfan4ever wrote: »
    you wildin manning is the most popular QB in the league by far cause of commercial, his father played in the NFL

    lol like brady doesnt have ad's in the magazine or on tv.....peyton's father past experience has nothing to do with peyton and his success
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • coop9889
    coop9889 Members Posts: 7,299 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    Peyton is definitely more popular than Brady
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Sep-00
    Sep-00 Members Posts: 210 ✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    regular season peyton but playoffs brady
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • MR.CJ
    MR.CJ Members Posts: 64,689 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    yea peyton is more popular than brady
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JUXcaptainHOOK
    JUXcaptainHOOK Members Posts: 406 ✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    to be honest ESPN be suckin Brady more... they just show there appreciation for Peyton more.. overall tho the most popular/powerful athletes in sports today are 1. Peyton Manning 2. Shaun White ... and thats coming from S.I.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • ghost!
    ghost! Members Posts: 7,370 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    Jeezyfan4ever wrote: »
    you wildin manning is the most popular QB in the league by far cause of commercial, his father played in the NFL

    .............................................................
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • pimped_out_red
    pimped_out_red Members Posts: 894 ✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    Tom is aggressive...Peyton has a more relaxed game(doesnt fire up the team)...

    2m76fs2.jpg
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • pimped_out_red
    pimped_out_red Members Posts: 894 ✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    This is who got next

    4930630097_b2af1e8ba6_o.gif
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • DOPEdweebz
    DOPEdweebz Members, Moderators, Writer Posts: 29,364 Regulator
    edited August 2011
    Options
    Tom Brady >>> Big Ben >> Peyt manning

    if peyt manning doesnt win that one superbowl he's A rod.. oh wait he is.. I guess that makes Tom Brady Jeter? The exception is the numbers of Brady are even better than peyt manning also, not just rings... but if I'm wrong just prove it to me. regular season wins, playoff wins, completion percentage overall or in a playoff game... i mean let's get to the FACTUAL CORE of this ? , and not base it off homerism or hatred.

    I mean just look at the ...

    Tags for this Thread
    Add / Edit Tags

    brady has 3 rings
    greatness
    nfl
    peyton has 1 ring
    peyton manning
    spy gate
    tom brady

    View Tag Cloud


    I'll admit tho I rather be early Tom Brady than Tom Brady lately, but I'd still take Tom Brady lately over Peyt manning from the past four years....
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • coop9889
    coop9889 Members Posts: 7,299 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    KingGivBiz wrote: »
    i mean let's get to the FACTUAL CORE of this ? , and not base it off homerism or hatred.



    Regular Season

    Career Games

    Manning: 208
    Brady: 145

    Most yards in a season

    Manning: 4,700 (2010) - 4,557 (2004) - 4,500 (2009)
    Brady: 4,806 (2007) - 4,398 (2009) - 4,110 (2005)

    Career Yards per Game {Games}

    Manning: 263.6
    Brady: 239.6

    Most TDs in a Season

    Manning: 49 (2004) - 33 (3 times) - 31 (2 times)
    Brady: 50 (2007) - 36 (2010) - 28 (3 times)

    Career TD per game

    Manning: 1.92
    Brady: 1.8

    Most INTs in a season

    Manning: 28 (1998) - 23 (2001) - 19 (2002)
    Brady: 14 (3 times) - 13 (2009) - 12 (3 times)

    Career INT per game

    Manning: 0.95
    Brady 0.71

    Best QB Ratings

    Manning: 121.1 (2004) - 104.1 (2005) - 101.0 (2006)
    Brady: 117.2 (2007) - 111.0 (2010) - 96.2 (2009)

    Career QB Rating

    Manning: 94.9
    Brady: 95.2

    Highest Completion %

    Manning: 68.8 (2009) - 67.6 (2004) - 67.3 (2005)
    Brady: 68.9 (2007) - 65.9 (2010) - 65.7 (2009)

    Career Completion %

    Manning: 64.9
    Brady: 63.6

    Most Fumbles in a Season

    Manning: 7 (2001) - 6 (4 times) - 5 (3 times)
    Brady: 13 (2003) - 12 (2 times) - 11 (2002)

    Career Fumbles per Game

    Manning: 0.27
    Brady: 0.5

    Regular Season Winning %

    Manning: 67.8
    Brady: 77.6


    MVPs

    Manning: 3.5
    Brady: 2

    POSTSEASON

    Games

    Manning: 19
    Brady: 19

    Winning Percentage {Record}

    Manning: 47.3 {9-10}
    Brady: 73.7 {14-5}

    TD - INT {Ratio}

    Manning: 29-19 {1.53}
    Brady: 30-16 {1.88}

    Completion Percentage

    Manning: 63.1
    Brady: 62.2

    Career Postseason Yards {Per Game}

    Manning: 5,389 {283.6}
    Brady: 4,407 {231.9}

    QB Rating

    Manning: 88.4
    Brady: 85.7

    Super Bowl Wins {MVPs}

    Manning: 1 {1}
    Brady: 3 {2}
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • JUXcaptainHOOK
    JUXcaptainHOOK Members Posts: 406 ✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    coop9889 wrote: »
    Regular Season

    Career Games

    Manning: 208
    Brady: 145

    Most yards in a season

    Manning: 4,700 (2010) - 4,557 (2004) - 4,500 (2009)
    Brady: 4,806 (2007) - 4,398 (2009) - 4,110 (2005)

    Career Yards per Game {Games}

    Manning: 263.6
    Brady: 239.6

    Most TDs in a Season

    Manning: 49 (2004) - 33 (3 times) - 31 (2 times)
    Brady: 50 (2007) - 36 (2010) - 28 (3 times)

    Career TD per game

    Manning: 1.92
    Brady: 1.8

    Most INTs in a season

    Manning: 28 (1998) - 23 (2001) - 19 (2002)
    Brady: 14 (3 times) - 13 (2009) - 12 (3 times)

    Career INT per game

    Manning: 0.95
    Brady 0.71

    Best QB Ratings

    Manning: 121.1 (2004) - 104.1 (2005) - 101.0 (2006)
    Brady: 117.2 (2007) - 111.0 (2010) - 96.2 (2009)

    Career QB Rating

    Manning: 94.9
    Brady: 95.2

    Highest Completion %

    Manning: 68.8 (2009) - 67.6 (2004) - 67.3 (2005)
    Brady: 68.9 (2007) - 65.9 (2010) - 65.7 (2009)

    Career Completion %

    Manning: 64.9
    Brady: 63.6

    Most Fumbles in a Season

    Manning: 7 (2001) - 6 (4 times) - 5 (3 times)
    Brady: 13 (2003) - 12 (2 times) - 11 (2002)

    Career Fumbles per Game

    Manning: 0.27
    Brady: 0.5

    Regular Season Winning %

    Manning: 67.8
    Brady: 77.6


    MVPs

    Manning: 3.5
    Brady: 2

    POSTSEASON

    Games

    Manning: 19
    Brady: 19

    Winning Percentage {Record}

    Manning: 47.3 {9-10}
    Brady: 73.7 {14-5}

    TD - INT {Ratio}

    Manning: 29-19 {1.53}
    Brady: 30-16 {1.88}

    Completion Percentage

    Manning: 63.1
    Brady: 62.2

    Career Postseason Yards {Per Game}

    Manning: 5,389 {283.6}
    Brady: 4,407 {231.9}

    QB Rating

    Manning: 88.4
    Brady: 85.7

    Super Bowl Wins {MVPs}

    Manning: 1 {1}
    Brady: 3 {2}

    Yup... u can close this thread now
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • ghost!
    ghost! Members Posts: 7,370 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    JUXcaptainHOOK wrote: »
    Yup... u can close this thread now

    dying at you that stats sheet didnt put anyone over...smh

    manning has been starting longer then brady, recorded more ints, and i think has one more playoff season a head of brady because brady was injuired in 08, and the big telling stats is superbowls...
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • coop9889
    coop9889 Members Posts: 7,299 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    ghost! wrote: »
    dying at you that stats sheet didnt put anyone over...smh

    manning has been starting longer then brady, recorded more ints, and i think has one more playoff season a head of brady because brady was injuired in 08, and the big telling stats is superbowls...

    Right... I didn't post those stats with the intention of showing anybody was better lol.

    If anything it makes them look more even.

    Manning usually has better completion %, yards
    Brady got the wins, better TD/INT ratio
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • ghost!
    ghost! Members Posts: 7,370 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 2011
    Options
    coop9889 wrote: »
    Right... I didn't post those stats with the intention of showing anybody was better lol.

    If anything it makes them look more even.

    Manning usually has better completion %, yards
    Brady got the wins, better TD/INT ratio

    yea na..i know u didnt....

    i was going at dude because i know he was trying to say those stats read for manning

    when really they just keep this arguement going between the two, brady's ahead of manning now, but it goes back n forth every year...at this point you're just better off waiting til they retired because they both should be adding more to their legacy.
    · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Categories