OBJECTIVELY is Eminem Top 10 DOA?

Options
1246710

Comments

  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    AZTG wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Mr.LV wrote: »
    Does Eminem have a better discography than
    Ghostface...no
    2pac.... no
    Nas..... no
    Kanye west....no
    Scarface......no
    BIG....no
    Common....no
    Jay Z ....no
    Ice Cube.... no
    LL Cool J..... no


    That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

    Em better then Kanye? Definetly.

    Em better than ghost and big? ? no.

    Well imo ghost one of the worst rappers ever

    If you want to say bigs first album is better than any Eminem album fine...i don't agree but eminems body of work is superior
  • power_wisdom
    power_wisdom Members Posts: 2,490 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is Top 10 DOA
    bck145 wrote: »
    AZTG wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Mr.LV wrote: »
    Does Eminem have a better discography than
    Ghostface...no
    2pac.... no
    Nas..... no
    Kanye west....no
    Scarface......no
    BIG....no
    Common....no
    Jay Z ....no
    Ice Cube.... no
    LL Cool J..... no


    That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

    Em better then Kanye? Definetly.

    Em better than ghost and big? ? no.

    Well imo ghost one of the worst rappers ever

    If you want to say bigs first album is better than any Eminem album fine...i don't agree but eminems body of work is superior

    Smh
  • TheGOAT
    TheGOAT Guests, Members, Writer, Content Producer Posts: 15,916 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is Top 10 DOA
    bck145 wrote: »
    AZTG wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Mr.LV wrote: »
    Does Eminem have a better discography than
    Ghostface...no
    2pac.... no
    Nas..... no
    Kanye west....no
    Scarface......no
    BIG....no
    Common....no
    Jay Z ....no
    Ice Cube.... no
    LL Cool J..... no


    That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

    Em better then Kanye? Definetly.

    Em better than ghost and big? ? no.

    Well imo ghost one of the worst rappers ever
    CDJo4EgHwbaPS.gif
  • chompollet
    chompollet Members Posts: 1,609 ✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Bck hates wu tang and prodigy.

  • jono
    jono Members Posts: 30,280 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited June 2017
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    Let's look at artists still alive (in no order):

    Cube
    Scarface
    Jay
    Nas
    Rakim
    Kane
    Chuck D
    Kanye
    Lupe
    DMX
    Snoop
    Common
    Killer Mike
    Beanie Sigel
    Jadakiss
    Styles P
    LL Cool J
    T.I.
    Andre 3000
    Bun B
    Krayzie Bone
    Twista
    Q Tip
    Busta Rhymes
    Method Man
    Ghostface

    This is just a list of some of the dudes I consider to be among the best living MCs. Eminem might be a better rhymer than some of them (objectively), he definitely sold more records than all of them but musically he's not on par.

    I can literally play LL records today, I can play BDK or Rakim records right now. Eminem? No.
    Is Eminem a better rapper than Styles P? Absolutely but I'll play G&AG before any Eminem album. I'll rock Time is Money before any Eminem album.

    Looking at everything, objectively, no. He's not top 10 DOA. He's had a major impact but theres living rappers with bigger impacts but sold fewer records.

    Look at that list. You got pioneers (LL, Rakim and BDK), you got trendsetters (Jay, Cube, Snoop, Chuck D), you got ? who influenced generations. You got Krayzie Bone who influenced the sing-song rap style that scored Nelly millions of albums sold and now that Drake is doing and sold millions of albums.

    You've got lyricists, ? that sold records, influenced styles and eras. Its easy as ? to bypass Eminem...objectively.
  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited June 2017
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    chompollet wrote: »
    Bck hates wu tang and prodigy.

    I don't hate prodigy....i don't overrate em like a lot of ppl do...also has nothing to do with this thread

    Go back In the oven
  • chompollet
    chompollet Members Posts: 1,609 ✭✭✭✭
    Options
    bck145 wrote: »
    chompollet wrote: »
    Bck hates wu tang and prodigy.

    I don't hate prodigy....i don't overrate em like a lot of ppl do...also has nothing to do with this thread

    Go back In the oven

    Shut up cracka come see me in the streets
  • rip.dilla
    rip.dilla Members Posts: 17,412 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    bck145 wrote: »
    AZTG wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Mr.LV wrote: »
    Does Eminem have a better discography than
    Ghostface...no
    2pac.... no
    Nas..... no
    Kanye west....no
    Scarface......no
    BIG....no
    Common....no
    Jay Z ....no
    Ice Cube.... no
    LL Cool J..... no


    That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

    Em better then Kanye? Definetly.

    Em better than ghost and big? ? no.

    Well imo ghost one of the worst rappers ever

    Straight up bannable statement... but you're a White kid anyway so what do you know?
  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    chompollet wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    chompollet wrote: »
    Bck hates wu tang and prodigy.

    I don't hate prodigy....i don't overrate em like a lot of ppl do...also has nothing to do with this thread

    Go back In the oven

    Shut up cracka come see me in the streets

    Bahaha bro you about as big as an apostrophe
  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    rip.dilla wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    AZTG wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Mr.LV wrote: »
    Does Eminem have a better discography than
    Ghostface...no
    2pac.... no
    Nas..... no
    Kanye west....no
    Scarface......no
    BIG....no
    Common....no
    Jay Z ....no
    Ice Cube.... no
    LL Cool J..... no


    That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

    Em better then Kanye? Definetly.

    Em better than ghost and big? ? no.

    Well imo ghost one of the worst rappers ever

    Straight up bannable statement... but you're a White kid anyway so what do you know?

    He can't rap....dont gotta get in your feelings over an opinion
  • VIBE
    VIBE Members Posts: 54,384 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    dope emcee, ? artist
  • KnowReasonForPeace
    KnowReasonForPeace Members Posts: 2,996 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    Top 15 and thats being generous. I got all his albums and he has 3 classics, but after the eminem show he fell the ? off hard like Jay Z did. ? didnt hear him on that most recent big sean collab? Thats rapping to be rapping and no type of substance. Filler bars.
  • Kwan Dai
    Kwan Dai Members Posts: 6,929 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    rip.dilla wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    AZTG wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Mr.LV wrote: »
    Does Eminem have a better discography than
    Ghostface...no
    2pac.... no
    Nas..... no
    Kanye west....no
    Scarface......no
    BIG....no
    Common....no
    Jay Z ....no
    Ice Cube.... no
    LL Cool J..... no


    That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

    Em better then Kanye? Definetly.

    Em better than ghost and big? ? no.

    Well imo ghost one of the worst rappers ever

    Straight up bannable statement... but you're a White kid anyway so what do you know?

    Seriously. How does a MF say something like this on a Hip Hop site?
  • chompollet
    chompollet Members Posts: 1,609 ✭✭✭✭
    edited June 2017
    Options
    I play hard for nine innings, dressed in fine linen
    ‘Cause ? is the best next thing besides winnin'
    All the positions I've been in couldn't explain how I'm livin'
    My vision, my intuition has risen
    Here, take a listen, I'm hittin'
    Up to bat with precision; see, I'm back in the kitchen
    Slinging ? to these pigeons, for the fact that I'm driven
    My linebackers is blitzin', send you packing, good riddance
    Trapped in this prison where snakes and rats is forbidden
    Keep my gun hitting, ? is ? signing petitions
    And they providing convictions
    See, I survive through the system under the livest conditions
    My riders ride on a mission
    For snitchin', you get your back blown right out of commission
    You'll be missin' like them crazy Christians
    And swimming with all the fishes
    Your Ms.'s will come and witness your body with hugs and kisses
    Now, tell me, is that nutritious?
    We party with chips and liquors
    Your wizzes is coming with us
    For real, kid, they bought me presents
    The difference is this is business, big biscuits, big figures
    We click on religious ? for acting too superstitious
    Move, ‘cause the Coupe is vicious
    Shoot if you want your wishes to blow
    See Trife in the Bentley with a group of ?
  • Busta Carmichael
    Busta Carmichael Members, Moderators Posts: 13,161 Regulator
    edited June 2017
    Options
    Ghostface can't Rap now?
    @bck145 what does your top 10 look like?
  • blacktux
    blacktux Members Posts: 4,559 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is Top 10 DOA
    Objectively from a technical standpoint i dont see how he can be argued out of a top 10
  • Kwan Dai
    Kwan Dai Members Posts: 6,929 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    blacktux wrote: »
    Objectively from a technical standpoint i dont see how he can be argued out of a top 10

    Because there are 10 other MC's more technical. What does that even mean though? "Technical"?

  • nawledge_god
    nawledge_god Members Posts: 5,622 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    Spite Vote
  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    Ghostface can't Rap now?
    @bck145 what does your top 10 look like?

    Tupac
    Nas
    Jay-Z
    Ice cube
    Joe budden
    Kurupt
    Scarface

    After that I don't really care too much....big daddy kane, kool g, talib, common, ll....i don't sit around and debate myself on a rappers list...it ain't that serious
  • power_wisdom
    power_wisdom Members Posts: 2,490 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is Top 10 DOA
    bck145 wrote: »
    Ghostface can't Rap now?
    @bck145 what does your top 10 look like?

    Tupac
    Nas
    Jay-Z
    Ice cube
    Joe budden
    Kurupt
    Scarface

    After that I don't really care too much....big daddy kane, kool g, talib, common, ll....i don't sit around and debate myself on a rappers list...it ain't that serious

    He ask you for 10 and you give him 7. Only you.
  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    bck145 wrote: »
    Ghostface can't Rap now?
    @bck145 what does your top 10 look like?

    Tupac
    Nas
    Jay-Z
    Ice cube
    Joe budden
    Kurupt
    Scarface

    After that I don't really care too much....big daddy kane, kool g, talib, common, ll....i don't sit around and debate myself on a rappers list...it ain't that serious

    He ask you for 10 and you give him 7. Only you.

    Yeah sorry I don't have all my favorite rappers mapped out in order....? I got ? to do
  • OGDirtyDee
    OGDirtyDee Members Posts: 1,699 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Sion wrote: »
    Of course he is but this is the IC and ? don't like Eminem because he's white straight up. That's the only reason cats on here don't like him. If you're being objective he's sold over 100 million albums, birthed the careers of 50 Cent/G-Unit and others. Dropped classic albums, had America on it's heels exposing the hypocrisy of American pop culture, became an ICON, influenced MOST rappers out today, has the respect of his peers and lyrically is easily one of the best to do it.

    ? of course he's top 10 EVER. Want to prove ? don't like him cuz he's white ? Make a thread asking if Eminem is a good lyricist, I will bet the IC will say he's not even in the top 20 let alone top 50 lyricists in rap today or of all time. It just is what it is, I don't even bother anymore, you can't fight fire with fire, in the end Eminem is going down as one of the GOAT and you can be mad af about it but it's just the truth.

    Truth but they favorite rappers will put Em in their top 10 if not 5. Jay Z, Nas, Kendrick, Cole, Drake, damn there all there all the heavyweights. He might not drop club bangers for the whip but IC be full of weird emotions when it comes to reality.
  • power_wisdom
    power_wisdom Members Posts: 2,490 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is Top 10 DOA
    bck145 wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Ghostface can't Rap now?
    @bck145 what does your top 10 look like?

    Tupac
    Nas
    Jay-Z
    Ice cube
    Joe budden
    Kurupt
    Scarface

    After that I don't really care too much....big daddy kane, kool g, talib, common, ll....i don't sit around and debate myself on a rappers list...it ain't that serious

    He ask you for 10 and you give him 7. Only you.

    Yeah sorry I don't have all my favorite rappers mapped out in order....? I got ? to do

    ? it's 10. What you flunk out of kindergarten?
  • bck145
    bck145 Members Posts: 4,997 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Options
    Objectively Eminem is NOT Top 10 DOA
    bck145 wrote: »
    bck145 wrote: »
    Ghostface can't Rap now?
    @bck145 what does your top 10 look like?

    Tupac
    Nas
    Jay-Z
    Ice cube
    Joe budden
    Kurupt
    Scarface

    After that I don't really care too much....big daddy kane, kool g, talib, common, ll....i don't sit around and debate myself on a rappers list...it ain't that serious

    He ask you for 10 and you give him 7. Only you.

    Yeah sorry I don't have all my favorite rappers mapped out in order....? I got ? to do

    ? it's 10. What you flunk out of kindergarten?

    Just because your nerd ass sits there making lists don't mean we all are ? boys like that....just enjoy the ? music...i swear y'all treat rappers like they your pops or some ?